Monday, January 28, 2013

Ruskin, Le Duc, and Semper


     As history began to approach the 19th century, cities began to change its way of life in regards to organization, jobs, materials, and goods which called for a new style of art and architecture to define and record their new era. Industrialization was on the rise, causing an influx of people from rural areas moving to the city, unhealthy and unorganized cities, and new materials and goods unable to produce by hand. New social problems, machines, and building materials called for a new ideology and form of architecture, “modern architecture,” given by these following men: Viollet le Duc, a theorist and writer, John Ruskin, and Gottfried Semper, both architects and writers, in order to solve these problems and record these significant inventions.

Arts & Crafts Style

     John Ruskin theories on architecture kind of took the Traditionalist approach, degenerating ideas from the past styles and continue to use them in modern architecture, but they also offered new ideas for the future of architecture (Colquhoun, 2002, p. 10). Ruskin believed that the new architecture should focus on the arts and crafts of previous styles. He was fascinated with high Gothic architecture (Pevsner). He did not like the idea of industrialization; he felt that industries were taking away the craftsmanship of architecture and making it immoral, requiring less labor, appearing less significant, and needing less time (Summerson, p. 656).

     Ruskin also believed in seven values of architecture, referred to as “The Seven Lamps of Architecture”, sacrifice, truth, power, beauty, life, memory, and obedience. Instead of restoring old historic buildings he thought they should preserve its ruins, because history was encoded in its decay. Restoring these buildings normally meant the use of another material would be involved to mimic the form of the original material, due to the age of the building. Ruskin believed in the truth of materials; therefore, he disagreed with the idea of restoration.

Detailed Literary Works
Detailed Border of a Page in a Literary Work 

Interior of a Residential Home during the Arts and Crafts Movement

Art Nouveau Style

      Viollet-le-Duc theories on architecture mostly disagreed with Ruskins; Le Duc took on a more Progressivist approach to architecture, wanting a style which reflected there age like the eras before them (Colquhoun, 2002, p. 10). He believed that “architects should find resources furnished by manufacturing skills and making use of these means with a view to the adoption of architectural forms adapted to our times”(Summerson, p. 656).

     Like Ruskin, Le Duc was also interested in gothic architecture (Pevsner). He was so fascinated that he analyzed how each gothic feature functioned by itself and as a whole in the structure and developed a dictionary and other literary works, Entretiens sur l’Architecture and the Dictionnaire Raisonne de l’Architecture Francaise, descriptively telling his readers how gothic buildings are made and how each component up to furniture function within the building. Through understanding the tectonics of gothic architecture, le Duc develops new ways to use the gothic style of architecture. In his later works and projects, he begins integrating steel and other metal materials into this archaic style of architecture.



Steel Structure Design done by Ville le Duc
Art Nouveau Interior Design
Many of the designs during this movement uphold this design to some certain extent


Der Still Style

     Gottfried Semper shared values of both Ruskin and le Duc, but also brings some new ideologies of architecture to the forefront. Like Ruskin, He was interested in the ornamentation of a building, not so much of the craftsmanship but the meaning and symbolism of this detailed art, and like le Duc, he was interested in the industrial production architecture could utilize in the future. Semper focused on how architecture styles could be compared in scientific and mathematical form, the taxonomy of architecture styles and form. He achieved this understanding by tracing back the history of individual art works and other influences, whether they were historical, material, or spiritual, that guided the birth and development of art. He was interested in the “formal laws and logic noticeable in the creation of architecture. “(Hvattum, Mar 2006, p. 136).

     With this idea, In 1851, He wrote The Four Elements of Architecture, which divided built forms into the following four categories: hearth, where elements of architecture group themselves like the residence flock around the fire of a house, platform, the basic level of a structure like living above ground, enclosure, the walls of a building like a fortress for protection, and the roof, which protects the unity of the elements like the roof protects the hearth from the rain.
the "Primitive Hut" or the "Four Elements of Architecture" described by Semper
Semper Speaks on Textiles and Weaving in his Literary Work "Der Still"

A painting done by Piet Mondrian during the De Stijl Movement

Conclusion

     Each of the previous writers and designers, Ruskin, le Duc, and Semper, influenced the future artistic and architecture styles of Arts and Crafts, Art Nouveau, and De Stijl, taking with them the following characteristics to develop art and architecture. Ruskin’s ideas founded the Arts and Crafts Movement where designers were interested in the handcraftsmanship of artworks and individuality of the craftsman and not machines. Le Duc designs inspired the Art Nouveau artist to leave materials and framework of a building exposed, organize spaces according to form vs function, design organic forms, and study vernacular domestic architecture (Colquhoun, 2002, p. 15). Semper wrote a literary work called Der Still which was written to understand and clarify process, but many misinterpreted his message about art for materialism and functionalism, inspiring many De Stijl artists to focus on simplicity of forms, abstraction, and use of color (History).

Citations: